Cross-position comparison — no head-to-head winner arrows. Each player's own projection categories are shown in their column.
Rest of Season Projection
AaronCategoryReid
Aaron Judge (RF)
28HR—
67R—
59RBI—
8SB—
.255AVG—
Reid Detmers (P)
—K131
—ERA2.91
—WHIP1.21
—W2–5
—SV0
Current Season
AaronCategoryReid
Aaron Judge (RF)
17HR—
43R—
38RBI—
5SB—
.248AVG—
Reid Detmers (P)
—K82
—ERA4.63
—WHIP1.18
—W2
—SV0
What Each Player's System Trusts
Aaron Judge
- xwobaSIGNALstable xwOBA 0.415, +0.100 vs league — production is earned
- hard_hit_pctSIGNALelite, already-stable contact quality
Reid Detmers
- xeraSIGNALstable xERA 2.91, 1.19 below league — production is earned
Judge projects for 28 HR and 8 SB, Detmers for 131 K and 2.91 ERA — different categories, so value depends on roster needs.