MLB Daily DeltaWeek 11 · June 8, 2026
Engraved portrait of Gerrit Cole
Gerrit Cole
NYY·P
Sell High high·0.75
Change to
Engraved portrait of Payton Tolle
Payton Tolle
BOS·P
Hold med·0.50
Change to

Rest of Season Projection

GerritCategoryPayton
97K 103
4.10ERA 3.75
1.30WHIP 1.28
4–9W 3–6
0SV0

Current Season

GerritCategoryPayton
12K 46
0.00ERA 2.61
0.71WHIP 0.90
1W 2
0SV0

What Each Player's System Trusts

Gerrit Cole
  • babip_againstNOISEBABIP-against 0.191 suppressed and unstable — flattering the ERA
  • xeraNOISEluck-free xERA 2.49 is 0.49 above the ERA — regression coming
Payton Tolle
  • xeraNOISEskill near league average (2.31)

Gerrit Cole: 97 K / 4.10 ERA. Payton Tolle: 103 K / 3.75 ERA. Different roster decisions — see individual verdicts.

Bare-stats comparison (narrative review pending).

Tweet

Related Comparisons