MLB Daily DeltaWeek 11 · June 5, 2026
Engraved portrait of Chase Shugart
Chase Shugart
PHI·P
Sell High high·0.95
Change to
Engraved portrait of Cooper Criswell
Cooper Criswell
SEA·P
Hold med·0.50
Change to

Rest of Season Projection

ChaseCategoryCooper
33K 27
3.70ERA 3.66
1.24WHIP1.24
2–6W 2–5
0SV 1–3

Current Season

ChaseCategoryCooper
20K 19
2.33ERA 3.08
0.93WHIP 1.10
2W2
0SV 1

What Each Player's System Trusts

Chase Shugart
  • babip_againstNOISEBABIP-against 0.244 suppressed and unstable — flattering the ERA
  • xeraNOISEluck-free xERA 3.48 is 1.15 above the ERA — regression coming
Cooper Criswell
  • xeraNOISEskill near league average (3.08)

Chase Shugart: 33 K / 3.70 ERA. Cooper Criswell: 27 K / 3.66 ERA. Different roster decisions — see individual verdicts.

Bare-stats comparison (narrative review pending).

Tweet

Related Comparisons